Bird flu and egg substitutes

It’s strange that so few people are talking about this flu outbreak in chickens in the US. I don’t think it’s something we can ignore. The outbreak is sad for many reasons, including the birds’ suffering, the needed yet wasteful culling of flocks, and the human toll of the workers dealing with so much death plus the farmers seeing their cared for animals and their business killed.

Frank and I visit Pete and Gerry’s egg farm in Vermont in October 2013.

We should expect a rise in egg prices, starting with liquid eggs and processed foods that use liquid eggs (including baked goods and ice cream, as the NY Times article states). I doubt in-shell egg prices are far behind. That’s bad news for people struggling to put food on the table. While there are many negatives here, I think the silver lining comes in two opportunities.

First, this is an opportunity to talk about the frailty of our food system. It doesn’t matter what type of farm you have, if an infected migratory bird shows up, your birds get sick. This issue spans all types of agriculture. What are farmers doing to protect their birds? How can the USDA and everyday consumers help?

Second, this is an opportunity to talk about egg alternatives. This issue spans many types of food; as any vegan could tell you, eggs are everywhere. There’s many foods that can replace eggs in home cooking and baking. Most processed food companies haven’t embraced alternatives in part because of cost. It’s just easier to get liquid eggs.

Now that liquid eggs are going to be more expensive for a while, it’s time for food scientists to figure out what can replace eggs in ice cream, bread, cookies, and other processed foods. Companies like Hampton Creek are developing egg substitute but that adds another layer of cost. Food companies may find that commercially produced egg alternatives work best, or they may be able to use a cheaper solution such as straight flax meal.

As a proponent of diverse food systems, I am excited about the potential for more use of egg substitutes. Since those substitutes are often made from less common crops like flax and cassava, there’s an opportunity for farmers to grow more complex crop rotations to meet this demand.

Anastasia Bodnar

Written by Anastasia Bodnar

Anastasia Bodnar serves as the Policy Director of Biology Fortified, Inc. She is a science communicator and multidisciplinary risk analyst with a career in federal service. She has a PhD in plant genetics and sustainable agriculture from Iowa State University.

5 comments

  1. We use applesauce in baking, which I think works out at twice the cost of eggs, tofu quite often in other cooking (4x the cost I believe, at least approximately) and a variety of other tricks and whatnot that I totally have no good handle on at all (we use ground flax seed, which works out being significantly cheaper than an egg also)
    It’ll be interesting how the market in general responds to any change in egg price, clearly at present the low cost of eggs is a major hurdle to adoption of egg alternatives in any product – at what point does the scale tip and egg become a none go to? (this would benefit me greatly, as the presence of egg in anything means that it doesn’t fit my self prescribed dietary choices, one would hope that ubiquity would drive prices down for substitutes also)

  2. Jean Santjer, a farmer in Minn. has posted several stories on this subject. on her page and she comments in gmo-skepti forum. I believe it has effected turkeys as well.

  3. Flaxseed meal and chia seeds work great in place of eggs when baking, and they are definitely cheaper than eggs to use! 1 tbsp.flaxeed meal + 3 tbsp. water = 1 egg in baking. The same ratio for chia seeds. Also, in some recipes 1/2 a mashed banana equals 1 egg. There are many alternatives.

  4. Yes turkeys have been affected too. The most recent update is that 40 million birds have been killed. Also, bird flu was found in an owl and a hawk too.

  5. Now i’m hungry for eggs. Well, they’re $2.99/doz large in this neck of the woods so they’re still a Michael Pollan bargain, who says we should be paying $8.00/doz.

Comments are closed.

Scroll Up