My name is Joe and I’m going to be an occasional guest blogger here at Biofortified. The area I write about is going to be a bit different than most of the other writers on this website. Instead of writing about genetically modified plants, I’m going to spend a large portion of my time writing about genetically modified insects and insect pathogens.
It may seem odd to some that a blog that mostly focuses on controversies in modern agriculture would ask someone who studies insects to write on their site, but it’s not as counter intuitive as you think. Insects are a huge part of agriculture because they are our biggest competitors for food. One of the most common types of genetically modified corn, the various BT cultivars, were developed to fight the European Corn Borer, Ostrinia nubilalis, which is a tiny Crambid moth which burrows into the stalks of the plants and eventually kills them.
An entomologist writing for a site which explores the politics of Genetically Modified Organisms makes sense for another reason, and that’s because entomologists sometimes modify the genes of insects in order to do their work. Some of this occurs naturally, through the actions of polydnavirus particles some parasitoid wasps inject into their hosts to control the behavior, development, and immune reactions of that host. Sometimes it’s simple and artificial such as releasing insects sterilized with X-ray radiation in order to fight diseases and crop pests. Some of the things that entomologists work with aren’t necessarily insects but are used to control their populations. A great example of this is the modification of viruses as systems which are used to deliver pesticides directly to the insects rather than spraying the environment with pesticides.
What I hope to do is to use this site to educate the public about some of the GMOs you may hear about on the news, and I hope to make people realize that these are wonderful inventions that better humanity. New things are definitely a little scary at first, but education is the best way to overcome these fears.
Since this is my first post, let’s explore some really basic insect biology that might be necessary to understand parts of my posts. Insects go through two types of development: hemimetabolous, or incomplete metamorphosis and holometabolous which is commonly known as complete metamorphosis.
Here’s an example of hemimetabolous or incomplete development. The video below depicts the life cycle of a cicada which begins as an egg and then develops through a series of nymphal stages before maturing into an adult. Notice how the adults are very similar to the nymphs with the obvious exception of wings. Also notice how they have a relatively similar ecological role, both feed on sap but in slightly different areas.
This is an example of holometabolous development. The butterfly in the video has a very strange parasitic relationship with ants. This butterfly goes through four stages: egg, larva, pupa and adult. Notice how the larva looks nothing like the adult, and how the larva has a completely different role than the adult. In this case, the adult feeds on nectar from flowers while the larva is a parasite in the ant nest.
3 comments
Comments are closed.
Hi Joe, great to have you writing about insects here. I might write a bit about genetically engineering honeybees in the future, and GE mosquitoes also come up in discussions. It’s an important topic, not as common as plants, but they have their own unique issues that plants don’t have.
With the discovery that RNAi can be done in honeybees through feeding, this might limit the applications that genetic engineering has for honeybees. We’ll see, though.
GE mosquitoes are an interesting topic…and even people who are normally all for genetic engineering tend to think of them in a ‘AAAAAAAAAH! MAD SCIENTIST’ sort of fashion.
So anytime we start genetically engineering animals, yeah…there are going to be different issues than we have with plants. I’m not quite sure why-it’s just the same concept but involving a different organism.
Anyways…I’m looking forward to writing more posts 🙂
I never learned the proper names for the two types of insect development. Thanks 🙂
I’m looking forward to posts on more genetically engineered insects, pesticide resistance, and more.
Regarding the mosquitoes, I have to admit I was a little “aaaah!” when I first heard about it, but once I learned more, it seems reasonable. I need to research it further, though. Whatever happened about that, anyway? It was in the news for a while and then just went away. My guess is that the regulatory hurdles squashed the project, at least for a while.